Fall bake sale treats are the perfect way to bring the cozy flavors of the season to your next event. From spiced cakes and cookies to pumpkin-filled goodies, these desserts are sure to stand out and delight.
These treats feature classic fall flavors like cinnamon, apple, caramel, and pumpkin, with warm spices that evoke the essence of autumn. Whether they’re topped with a sweet glaze, dusted with cinnamon sugar, or drizzled with caramel, these desserts capture the flavors of the season.
We’ve selected these fall bake sale treat ideas based on their festive appeal, easy preparation, and crowd-pleasing flavors. These baked goods are perfect for sharing at your next fall event or bake sale, bringing a delicious taste of autumn to all who try them.
Pumpkin Pie Rice Krispie Treats
Pumpkin pie Rice Krispie treats are a no-bake dessert made in a pie pan, resembling a pumpkin pie. With an ornage Rice Krispie base and a whipped topping "crust", it’s a creative twist on the classic pie.
Why its good: This no bake treat is easy to whip up in about 20 minutes.
Turkey Leg Rice Krispie Treats
Turkey leg Rice Krispie treats are shaped like turkey legs and coated with chocolate for a fun, seasonal treat.
Why its good: These are a fun thanksgiving themed addition that is an easy, no bake option.
Pumpkin Cake Balls
Pumpkin cake balls are moist cake bites mixed with frosting and coated in chocolate, offering a poppable dessert option.
Why its good: Their festive appearance and rich pumpkin flavor make them a hit at fall bake sales.
Mini Apple Pie Tarts
Mini apple pie tarts are bite-sized treats filled with spiced apples and baked to golden perfection, making them easy to serve and eat.
Why its good: These adorable tarts are perfect for individual portions and bring a seasonal flavor to your bake sale.
Apple Pie Cupcakes
Apple pie cupcakes combine spiced cake with a gooey apple pie filling, all topped with a cinnamon frosting for a cozy fall treat.
why they're good: These cupcakes offer the comfort of apple pie with the convenience of a handheld dessert.
No-Bake Pumpkin Pie
This no-bake pumpkin pie features a creamy, spiced filling on a graham cracker crust, perfect for quick and easy fall desserts.
why it's good: Simple to make and full of seasonal flavor, this pie is a great choice for a bake sale.
Apple Crunch Cheesecake
Apple crunch cheesecake layers spiced apples, creamy cheesecake, and a crunchy topping for a decadent dessert.
Why its good: Its layered textures and flavors make it a show-stopping treat for any fall bake sale.
Biscoff Cupcakes
Biscoff cupcakes feature spiced cupcakes topped with creamy Biscoff-flavored frosting, making them rich and indulgent.
Why its good: Their unique flavor and festive presentation make them a standout item for a fall bake sale.
Apple Pie Cookies
Apple pie cookies are miniature versions of the classic dessert, complete with a flaky crust and spiced apple filling.
Why its good: These bite-sized pies are as cute as they are delicious, perfect for bake sales and fall gatherings.
Caramel Apple Cookies
These soft caramel apple cookies feature bits of caramel and apple, blending the flavors of a caramel apple into a cozy cookie.
Why its good: With their seasonal flavors, they’re a crowd-pleasing addition to any fall treat table.
Pumpkin Pie Cookies
Pumpkin pie cookies capture the essence of pumpkin pie with their spiced flavor and soft texture, perfect for seasonal cravings.
Why its good: These cookies bring classic fall flavors in an easy-to-eat package, making them a bake sale staple.
Carrot Cake Cookies
Carrot cake cookies are spiced cookies with grated carrots and cream cheese frosting for a handheld version of the classic dessert.
Why its good: Their warm spices and creamy frosting make them a perfect match for fall bake sales.
Everything Cookies
Everything cookies are packed with mix-ins like oats, chocolate, nuts, and more, offering a satisfying bite in every cookie.
Why its good: Their hearty, homemade appeal makes them an all-around favorite for bake sale buyers.
Pancake Mix Cookies
Pancake mix cookies are quick to make with a soft texture and customizable mix-ins, like chocolate chips or sprinkles.
Why its good: Simple and versatile, these cookies are a great option for last-minute additions to your bake sale.
Reeses Pieces Cookies
These reeses pieces cookies combine the nuttiness of peanut butter with the crunch and bright colors of Reese’s Pieces, making them a seasonal delight.
Why its good: Their festive colors and classic flavors make them a popular and easy sell at any fall bake sale.
Turkey Rice Krispie Treats
Turkey Rice Krispie treats are a festive, no-bake dessert decorated to look like turkeys using candy decorations.
Why its good: Fun and creative, these treats are a hit with kids and a great option for a fall-themed bake sale.
Chocolate Caramel Rice Krispies
Chocolate caramel Rice Krispie treats are mixed with gooey caramel and rich chocolate for a decadent twist on the classic dessert.
Why its good: With their indulgent flavors, these treats are sure to draw attention at your bake sale.
Chocolate Dipped Rice Krispie Treats
Chocolate-dipped Rice Krispie treats are classic marshmallow and cereal squares partially coated in chocolate and sprinkles for a festive touch.
Why its good: This no bake treat uses just 4 ingredients. And, the sprinkles can be customized to different colors and themes.
Pumpkin Spice Rice Krispie Treats
Pumpkin spice Rice Krispie treats are flavored with warm spices, turning a classic treat into a seasonal favorite.
Why its good: Easy to make and full of fall flavor, these are a perfect addition to any bake sale lineup.
Candy Corn Rice Krispie Treats
Cany corn rice krispie treats are all the goodness of a classic rice krispie, but with candy corns mixed in. They are a fun colorful candy addition.
Why its good: This no bake treat is super easy to make, using just 4 ingredients and about 15 minutes.
Bischoff Rice Krispie Treats
Biscoff Rice Krispie treats are classic marshmallow squares with a spiced Biscoff twist, creating a fall-inspired flavor.
Why its good: These simple and nostalgic treats are elevated with warm spices.
Tiramisu Cookies
Tiramisu cookies feature coffee-flavored dough and a mascarpone frosting, dusted with cocoa powder for a sophisticated dessert.
Why its good: These elegant cookies stand out with their unique flavor and upscale presentation, ideal for fall events.
Peanut Butter Fudge
Peanut butter fudge is rich, creamy, and easy to make with just two ingredients. It’s cut into squares for a perfect bite-sized treat.
Why its good: These indulgent squares are an irresistible addition to any bake sale table and a favorite among peanut butter fans.
Snickerdoodle Cookies
Snickerdoodle cookies are soft and buttery with a cinnamon-sugar coating, making them a timeless fall favorite.
Why its good: Their classic flavor and simplicity make them a reliable choice for a bake sale.
Caramel Apple Slices
Caramel apple slices are apple wedges dipped in caramel and topped with sprinkles, nuts, or chocolate drizzle for a sweet, crunchy snack.
Why its good: These treats are a modern take on a fall classic, offering all the flavor of caramel apples in an easier-to-eat format.
Apple Pie Empanadas
Apple empanadas are hand-held pastries filled with spiced apple filling and baked until golden brown. Their flaky crust and warm flavor make them irresistible.
Why its good: These portable treats are perfect for bake sales, offering a comforting fall flavor in a convenient size.
Candy Corn Cookies
Candy corn cookies are soft, thick, and perfect for fall, with candy corn pieces baked right in. They bring festive fall colors and a sweet flavor to your bake sale.
Why its good: These colorful cookies are easy to make with a no chill dough.
